Comments on post #2647671

@DanbooruBot on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-08-27T21:02:28-04:00

RaisingK replaced this post with a new image:

Old	www.pixiv.net/member_illust.php?mode=medium&illust_id=61584424	2ad7953450eaeb1bc89bc230f07801f9	png	1019 x 640	615.5 KB
New	i.pximg.net/img-original/img/2017/02/22/19/00/22/61584424_p0.png	92bf85b53f922de139049c5ef5fc851a	png	1019 x 640	910.2 KB

@Astolfo on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-08T12:11:46-05:00

Reapproved this, it's good enough art to overlook the self-upload; so long as the uploader does not do it again.

@ddd666 on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-08T11:12:35-05:00

I think the quality is fine enough to be passed.
If this is getting rejected because of self-uploading, then I believe the rule should be changed to just "prohibited" not "may be disputable".

@user_460797 on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-08T09:33:04-05:00

Gollgagh said:

This is actually good art though.

Exactly.
Like I said: Uploading own art is frowned upon, off course. The image per se looks absolutely fine, though. And because this flag reason doesn't mention quality issues, I think it's just again a hardline flag.

@Gollgagh on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-08T09:29:59-05:00

This is actually good art though.

@arisboch on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-08T09:20:57-05:00

That was silly of the uploader, why wouldn't s/he just create a sock puppet account with another name and upload it using that? It's easily done. Or have it someone else upload it. Damn, how silly of him/her.

@MMaestro on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-06T16:41:01-05:00

hoodrager said:

I've never seen a case like this where it gets approved so i assumed it was outright forbidden.

I have. Its rare, but it happens; theres a repeated discussion just like this, the picture is approved/deleted, people eventually forget and the loop starts all over again.

@hoodrager on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-06T15:53:06-05:00

arisboch said:

AFAIK it's not forbidden, but just "frowned up" or something like that.

I've never seen a case like this where it gets approved so i assumed it was outright forbidden.

@user_460797 on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-06T13:42:09-05:00

arisboch said:

AFAIK it's not forbidden, but just "frowned up" or something like that.

Too much higher scrutiny. And I'm really wavering for three days now if I should approve it. It really isn't bad in my eyes.

But the uploader should be contacted if they continue, @flippyz15

@arisboch on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-06T13:39:13-05:00

hoodrager said:

uploading one's own art i believe since the user name and tag match.

AFAIK it's not forbidden, but just "frowned up" or something like that.

@hoodrager on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-05T11:54:24-05:00

arisboch said:

And what rule does that picture violate?

uploading one's own art i believe since the user name and tag match.

@arisboch on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-05T11:44:46-05:00

linoth said:

You might want to review the rules you agreed to when you signed up, particularly the prohibited and restricted content section.

And what rule does that picture violate?

@linoth on post #2647671 (tooru, kobayashi, and tooru (kobayashi-san chi no maidragon) drawn by flippyz15)

2017-03-03T14:45:22-05:00

You might want to review the rules you agreed to when you signed up, particularly the prohibited and restricted content section.