Comments

blindVigil

nonamethanks said:

It's a meme reference, of course they're the same. We still don't tag the characters if they're not in the picture though, unless there's no other way to find the picture. But this is a famous scene, so a tag for it will suffice.

That really doesn't make any sense to me. If it was just the pose, I could understand. Almost all of the examples you listed are also just other characters doing the poses/scenes, so of course you wouldn't tag the referenced characters there. But I don't see how that applies as well to an image where the four characters depicted are exact copies of four specific named characters, down to every facial detail, with the only difference being skin color.

That sounds honestly ridiculous, but I'm not gonna get into a fight over it.

Tomzai

1 day ago

nonamethanks said:

Also changed the artist name to add a qualifier. Next time don't nuke a gentag just because you want to replace it with an artist name.

That's first time that happened for me, i assure you it was not intentional. I somehow assumed that it would automatically differentiate the tags, i stand corrected.

nonamethanks said:

It's a meme reference, of course they're the same. We still don't tag the characters if they're not in the picture though, unless there's no other way to find the picture. But this is a famous scene, so a tag for it will suffice.
Here's another bunch of exact jojo references where we don't tag the characters:
oh?_you're_approaching_me?
kono_dio_da -dio_brando (some are tagged with the character but only because the face is copypasted from the original scene, like post #3573936)
yes_i_am! -mohammed_avdol
daga_kotowaru -kishibe_rohan
taste_of_a_liar -bruno_buccellati

So you're saying that because that one picture has copypasted face from the anime (and only the face), it's eligible to be tagged with the character tag. But in this case where the artist has drawn the characters so close to the original (physique and face feature -wise) that from a glance someone could even think those are traced, but because the skin color, hairstyle and clothes are different, it doesn't count?

Is that how it works? Is there any written guideline to this? Honestly im curious.

Sanic Hegehog

1 day ago

I mean, I can see Avdol in the back, but I don't know any of the others.

Valentine322

1 day ago

Sanic_Hegehog said:

I mean, I can see Avdol in the back, but I don't know any of the others.

The one in front is definitely Joseph. The jawline is far too noticeable.
That said, Kakyoin and Jotaro is a bit less clear for me.

iridescent slime

about 24 hours ago

Tomzai said:

That's first time that happened for me, i assure you it was not intentional. I somehow assumed that it would automatically differentiate the tags, i stand corrected.

I'm not calling you a liar, but how do you unintentionally remove a tag from nine other posts? Changing a general tag into an artist tag doesn't remove it from anywhere; it just makes the tag turn red. Unless you're using some sort of a script you would have had to manually remove the tag from each post individually, so what did you expect would happen after that?

Tomzai

3 minutes ago

iridescent_slime said:

I'm not calling you a liar, but how do you unintentionally remove a tag from nine other posts? Changing a general tag into an artist tag doesn't remove it from anywhere; it just makes the tag turn red. Unless you're using some sort of a script you would have had to manually remove the tag from each post individually, so what did you expect would happen after that?

Since the artist tag and the general tag where (at that time) the same, i went and untagged the now incorrect artist tag since i couldnt figure out what else to do that point, so i at least did that.

I intended to do something about it later but someone else got to it first.