"undressing" tag

@jxh2154: 3000+ vs 200... I say alias it.

2008-08-30T00:04:54-04:00

3000+ vs 200... I say alias it.

@スラッシュ: Are we keeping dressing then?

2008-08-29T09:46:23-04:00

Are we keeping dressing then?

@jxh2154: Another vote in favor of just leaving the...

2008-08-29T08:57:41-04:00

Another vote in favor of just leaving the status quo. undressing works.

@0xCCBA696: It's explained perfectly clearly in the wiki...

2008-08-29T08:13:15-04:00

It's explained perfectly clearly in the wiki page, and frankly there are going to be a lot more people searching for undressing than dressing, and certainly more than changing_clothes. Just leave it as is. We don't really need an alias either, but it's a possibility.

@スラッシュ: Perhaps the tag could be clarified somehow, so...

2008-08-29T06:59:47-04:00

Perhaps the tag could be clarified somehow, so that both dressing and undressing are included. I'm not sure what that would be, maybe something like changing_clothes (I don't particularly like that one, though). Then, both dressing and undressing could be aliased to it.

@RaisingK: Indeed, and whether it's undressing or...

2008-08-29T06:44:08-04:00

Indeed, and whether it's undressing or dressing, the situation captured by the picture is mostly the same. Undressing has more, so how about just putting in an alias to change dressing to undressing?

@Shinjidude: I believe the rationale was that for most...

2008-08-29T06:32:56-04:00

I believe the rationale was that for most pictures, it is difficult to tell which direction the action is going. For your image there is context, but for many it's just a girl standing there half clothed, holding something she's either just taken off or is about to put on.

Because of the ambiguity it was decided to use undressing for both cases. I believe another situation that fell in this whole directionality business was sunrise vs sunset, though I see that right now the former has a handful of posts, at the time it was decided to just tag everything as sunset, since it was hard to tell which direction the sun was going.

In all honesty I didn't even know we were using dressing at all.

Another, less well motivated rationale behind this sort of temporal direction bashing is that sunrise/sunset look about the same, as do dressing/undressing usually. Therefore someone searching for one would probably be interested in the other. By combining the tags, you get more results without a more complicated query.

[Edit] forum #7135 is the place this was previously discussed

@bluishwolf: It's difficult to tell if someone is undressing...

2008-08-29T06:32:45-04:00

It's difficult to tell if someone is undressing or dressing

@cnmanx: this explanation might be a bit simple, but...

2008-08-29T06:24:05-04:00

this explanation might be a bit simple, but maybe it was just mistagged there ? =)

@Ichigo69: I was looking at post #260496 and it had...

2008-08-29T06:16:42-04:00

I was looking at post #260496 and it had 'undressing' as a tag when obviously Naga and Lina were in the act of getting dressed. It's morning and they're obviously late b/c Lina's got the stereotypical toast in her mouth a la Miyuki-chan in Wonderland. However, when you look at the wiki for 'undressing' it says "When someone is in the middle of taking off (or putting on) their clothes."

Could someone please explain this to me??? Undressing does NOT include the act of putting on your clothes. Or at least where I come from it doesn't -__^ Also, there's a 'dressing' tag with 214 pictures attached to it. Anyway, Albert or somebody, could one of you guys clarify this?

Cheers!