Tag alias: one_leg_raised -> leg_up

@albert: The tag alias one_leg_raised -> leg_up has been...

2016-03-26T12:27:05-04:00

The tag alias one_leg_raised -> leg_up has been rejected.

@user_460797: > MyrMindservant said: > > Previous discussion...

2016-03-15T17:43:15-04:00

MyrMindservant said:

Previous discussion related to this: topic #12517

One possible way to deal with this is to clarify/redefine one_leg_raised and use it for posts where only the lower leg was raised. Then it could be either made a subset of leg_up or used as an alternative, depending on chosen definition of leg_up.

If we go with definition that leg_up should be for posts where the entire leg is raised, then it would be something like this:
one_leg_raised: post #2296963, post #2294180, post #2304348
leg_up: post #2263209, post #2294396, post #2297585

These posts are less obvious, but should still fall under leg_up: post #2259115, post #2288524

And these ones I'm not sure about: post #2294927, post #2293917
leg_up seems to be the most appropriate tag here, but it's not the entire leg in these cases.

I'd use feet_up for the last two pics since it's only one part of the leg (that has importance for pictures) is lifted. But if the thigh is also lifted I'd always use leg up or one leg raised.
post #2302330 leg_up
post #2292279 feet_up
post #2281859 knee_up
post #2304321 knees_up (Both knee-tag would I use if the character is sitting or lying.)

But I see that those tags need clean-up.

@MyrMindservant: Previous discussion related to this: topic...

2016-03-15T17:17:39-04:00

Previous discussion related to this: topic #12517

One possible way to deal with this is to clarify/redefine one_leg_raised and use it for posts where only the lower leg was raised. Then it could be either made a subset of leg_up or used as an alternative, depending on chosen definition of leg_up.

If we go with definition that leg_up should be for posts where the entire leg is raised, then it would be something like this:
one_leg_raised: post #2296963, post #2294180, post #2304348
leg_up: post #2263209, post #2294396, post #2297585

These posts are less obvious, but should still fall under leg_up: post #2259115, post #2288524

And these ones I'm not sure about: post #2294927, post #2293917
leg_up seems to be the most appropriate tag here, but it's not the entire leg in these cases.

@user_460797: > nom123 said: > > It is already pointed out...

2016-03-08T12:09:26-05:00

nom123 said:

It is already pointed out in forum #111556 that leg_up means the entire leg is raised, while knee_up means only the knee is raised. It seems that one_leg_raised actually covers these two tags.

Hmm, I don't really see where you read this.
Knee up is more specific since it's a certain part of the leg. And yes, I do think here that knee up shouldn't imply leg up since both ones are pretty unique. But one leg raised literally says that one unspecific part of the leg is raised (most times the whole thing). It wouldn't even confuse users in my opinion, exact the contrary, it's cleaning up the tags.

@Nitrogen09: It is already pointed out in forum #111556 that...

2016-03-08T07:51:11-05:00

It is already pointed out in forum #111556 that leg_up means the entire leg is raised, while knee_up means only the knee is raised. It seems that one_leg_raised actually covers these two tags.

@user_460797: create alias one_leg_raised -> leg_up Link to...

2016-03-07T19:10:37-05:00

create alias one_leg_raised -> leg_up

Link to alias

Hmm, I guess this was discussed before and since we have a seperate tag (two_legs_up) those two tags are basically the same thing.