tag:danbooru.me,2005:/forum_topics/6083Tagging of Succubi2011-05-08T13:35:45-04:00tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/621202011-05-08T13:35:45-04:002011-05-08T13:35:45-04:00@Arrei: > glasnost said:
> Not this, though. OP had it...<blockquote><p>glasnost said:<br>Not this, though. OP had it right in referencing the <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/vampire">vampire</a> tag; that's the model <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a> should follow.</p></blockquote><p>Well, it's a little bit of a gray area. I slipped up when I mentioned Morrigan - I meant it more in the case of beings like the Disgaea succubus: she's actually called succubus, so it doesn't seem like it'd make much sense to not tag her as succubus.</p>Arrei/users/324239tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/621152011-05-08T12:04:50-04:002011-05-08T12:04:50-04:00@jxh2154: No alias then, as it's far from unanimous.<p>No alias then, as it's far from unanimous.</p>jxh2154/users/1309tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/621042011-05-08T11:40:24-04:002011-05-08T11:40:24-04:00@glasnost: > Arrei said:
> Perhaps it should be restricted...<blockquote><p>Arrei said:<br>Perhaps it should be restricted to images where the succubus is doing something seductive, then?</p></blockquote><p>That, and images where text unambiguously identifies the character as a succubus.</p><blockquote><p>Arrei said:<br>And certain cases where the character is definitely a succubus, perhaps. Like the Disgaea succubus and Morrigan, but not for originals or "unconfirmed" succubi that just look like demon girls.</p></blockquote><p>Not this, though. OP had it right in referencing the <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/vampire">vampire</a> tag; that's the model <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a> should follow.</p>glasnost/users/60288tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/621022011-05-08T11:25:33-04:002011-05-08T11:31:41-04:00@Arrei: Perhaps it should be restricted to images where...<p>Perhaps it should be restricted to images where the succubus is doing something seductive, then?</p><p>And certain cases where the character is definitely a succubus, perhaps. Like the Disgaea succubus and Morrigan, but not for originals or "unconfirmed" succubi that just look like demon girls.</p>Arrei/users/324239tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620902011-05-08T08:09:53-04:002011-05-08T08:10:18-04:00@zatchii: I don't think an alias is necessary, since...<p>I don't think an alias is necessary, since succubi can be recognized by succubus-like behaviour, and accompanying text like <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-post-id-link" href="/posts/869902">post #869902</a> and <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-post-id-link" href="/posts/525610">post #525610</a>.</p><p>We should probably do like with <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/vampire">vampire</a> and omit the tag in cases where they're indistinguishable from an ordinary <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/demon_girl">demon girl</a>.</p>zatchii/users/30735tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620822011-05-08T00:41:15-04:002011-05-08T00:41:15-04:00@Fred1515: There are also images of succubi doing their...<p>There are also images of succubi doing their classic "sucking men's life force through sex" thing. For example, <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-post-id-link" href="/posts/66118">post #66118</a>, <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-post-id-link" href="/posts/328062">post #328062</a> and <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-post-id-link" href="/posts/328057">post #328057</a>. Such posts are apparently a very tiny fraction of the tag, but since they do exist an alias is probably not a good idea.</p>Fred1515/users/97403tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620792011-05-07T19:21:03-04:002011-05-07T19:21:03-04:00@Saladofstones: I'm not really in support of it, there are...<p>I'm not really in support of it, there are issues with it since succubus can be something that is tagged with appropriate information, and not all demon girls are succubi. </p>Saladofstones/users/318380tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620772011-05-07T17:17:46-04:002011-05-07T17:17:46-04:00@Cyberia-Mix: That may be just me but when I think succubus,...<p>That may be just me but when I think <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a>, criteria include normal skin or red/pink skin, and a tail.<br>If the tail was missing and/or skin was of a different color (like blue or green), I wouldn't count the character as a <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a> but still as a <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/demon_girl">demon_girl</a>.<br>But that's really my personal feeling anyway so YMMV.</p>Cyberia-Mix/users/227562tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620762011-05-07T17:04:34-04:002011-05-07T17:04:34-04:00@eidolon: I'm in favor for an alias.<p>I'm in favor for an alias.</p>eidolon/users/63502tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/620342011-05-07T09:31:37-04:002011-05-07T09:31:37-04:00@jxh2154: I'm okay with it too, but we'll need more...<p>I'm okay with it too, but we'll need more people to comment in support (or opposition) before I go aliasing a tag with 1,434 images out of existence.</p>jxh2154/users/1309tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/619132011-05-04T00:41:44-04:002011-05-04T00:41:44-04:00@Magus: The standard physical traits for succubi are...<p>The standard physical traits for succubi are bat-like wings and a tail, but neither are exclusive to them. So I'm on board for that alias.</p>Magus/users/15864tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/619052011-05-03T19:06:35-04:002011-05-03T19:06:35-04:00@evazion: > Dogenzaka said:
> Do succubi even have set...<blockquote><p>Dogenzaka said:<br>Do succubi even have set physical traits besides wings and a tail that set them apart from other demonic characters?</p></blockquote><p>Not in my opinion. I proposed a <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a> -> <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/demon_girl">demon girl</a> alias in <a class="dtext-link dtext-id-link dtext-forum-post-id-link" href="/forum_posts/22972">forum #22972</a> but that didn't gain much traction.</p>evazion/users/52664tag:danbooru.me,2005:ForumPost/619002011-05-03T16:58:39-04:002011-05-08T13:35:45-04:00@Dogenzaka: I know that we don't tag vampires as such...<p>I know that we don't tag <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/vampire">vampires</a> as such unless we can clearly see the character's vampiric traits, but what about Succubi? I always tag <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-4" href="/wiki_pages/morrigan_aensland">Morrigan_Aensland</a> as a <a class="dtext-link dtext-wiki-link tag-type-0" href="/wiki_pages/succubus">succubus</a>, and am wondering if I should be more selective. Do succubi even have set physical traits besides wings and a tail that set them apart from other demonic characters?</p>Dogenzaka/users/211243