Tag Suggestion; Fairy_tale

@Zekana: Added the_tortoise_and_the_hare to the list. ...

2011-06-07T13:15:08-04:00

Added the_tortoise_and_the_hare to the list. I'm surprised how little this tag is used.

and ya, if it says kaguya hime IS a character from tale of the bamboo cutter, then I don't see any reason it shouldn't be a character tag.

@sgcdonmai: The wiki page for kaguya hime lists it as a...

2011-06-07T12:12:22-04:00

The wiki page for kaguya hime lists it as a specific character from the tale of the bamboo cutter/Taketori Monogatari. It should definitely be a char: tag rather than a copy: tag, and all of the relevant images should be given the tale of the bamboo cutter tag as well.

@Saladofstones: > EB said: > Most of the images relating to it...

2011-06-06T20:53:55-04:00

EB said:
Most of the images relating to it are tagged with the alternate name, kaguya_hime (used as a copyright and not a character).

I would rather go with the tale of the bamboo cuter, since the story of Kaguya_hime falls into the umbrella of the former rather than the other way around.

The problem with this is that from what I can tell, they seem to be two separate telling of the same basic story.

@EB: > Zekana said: > tale_of_the_bamboo_cutter...

2011-06-06T12:36:16-04:00

Zekana said:
tale_of_the_bamboo_cutter (this one needs some tagging help)

Most of the images relating to it are tagged with the alternate name, kaguya_hime (used as a copyright and not a character).

@alegria: I edited the wiki for folklore and added some...

2011-06-06T11:33:49-04:00

I edited the wiki for folklore and added some links. I'm sure I missed quite a few, so please look it over.

No one's rushing to add this tag to images, so maybe it should be a tag group instead?

@jxh2154: > UnderneathTheWaves said: > I think we should...

2011-05-18T16:46:46-04:00

UnderneathTheWaves said:
I think we should un-alias folklore and use that. It's more inclusive than fairy_tail and illustrates the point of the tag better.

Removed the existing folklore alias so it's open now.

@UTW: I think we should un-alias folklore and use...

2011-05-09T18:06:49-04:00

I think we should un-alias folklore and use that. It's more inclusive than fairy_tail and illustrates the point of the tag better. Add a _(game) qualifier to folklore, alias that to Folkssoul, and add a note to the bottom of the folklore wiki if need be.

@juunigatsu_no_usagi: Thanks.

2011-05-09T17:48:06-04:00

Thanks.

@Log: big_bad_wolf_(grimm)

2011-05-09T17:02:54-04:00

big_bad_wolf_(grimm)

@juunigatsu_no_usagi: Who removed big bad wolf from the red riding...

2011-05-09T16:49:22-04:00

Who removed big bad wolf from the red riding hood pics?

Anyway, I like the Folklore tag

@Saladofstones: > sgcdonmai said: > I would suggest caution to...

2011-05-08T15:46:50-04:00

sgcdonmai said:
I would suggest caution to avoid polluting the folklore tags; some major game series and anime characters are outright shout-outs to the old fairly tales, and it wouldn't make a lot of sense to tag those except in very, very exceptional cases.

Example: bulleta, from the vampire_(game) series (who is unmistakably Little Red Riding Hood gone bad), or houraisan kaguya from touhou (who is, in-game, one and the same with Kaguya-hime of Taketori Monogatari).

I think we should limit to cases where the tale_of_the_bamboo_cutter is referenced too, as the example did.

@sgcdonmai: I would suggest caution to avoid polluting the...

2011-05-08T15:20:11-04:00

I would suggest caution to avoid polluting the folklore tags; some major game series and anime characters are outright shout-outs to the old fairly tales, and it wouldn't make a lot of sense to tag those except in very, very exceptional cases.

Example: bulleta, from the vampire_(game) series (who is unmistakably Little Red Riding Hood gone bad), or houraisan kaguya from touhou (who is, in-game, one and the same with Kaguya-hime of Taketori Monogatari).

@Zekana: Well, if there are no issues with the tag, then...

2011-05-08T14:59:17-04:00

Well, if there are no issues with the tag, then I think we should start posting tags already in place that would fall under Fairy_tale.

Little_red_riding_hood
honest_axe
tale_of_the_bamboo_cutter (this one needs some tagging help)

Are there any other tags that are already on the site, as well as others that aren't yet created but should be included in a Fairy_tale?

@Saladofstones: > Zekana said: > I think it would be worth it. ...

2011-05-02T19:07:46-04:00

Zekana said:
I think it would be worth it. It would help to identify what story the image is based off of, plus if little_red_riding_hood gets a tag, i think its fair for other stories to get tags as well.

Only issue i see is what would count as a fairy tale and what wouldn't? Should we add Greek stories and Epic Poems as well? should stories from the Bible count as fairy tales too?

also, does pixiv have tags for these stories? that alone would help tagging images that are already on the site.

I think we should separate fairy tales from mythology and religious tales.

@Zekana: > Anelaid said: > Would it be worth adding the...

2011-05-02T18:52:07-04:00

Anelaid said:
Would it be worth adding the specific fairy tale if its known as well?

I think it would be worth it. It would help to identify what story the image is based off of, plus if little_red_riding_hood gets a tag, i think its fair for other stories to get tags as well.

Only issue i see is what would count as a fairy tale and what wouldn't? Should we add Greek stories and Epic Poems as well? should stories from the Bible count as fairy tales too?

also, does pixiv have tags for these stories? that alone would help tagging images that are already on the site.

@Saladofstones: Would it be worth adding the specific fairy...

2011-05-02T17:20:13-04:00

Would it be worth adding the specific fairy tale if its known as well?

@rantuyetmai: I'd love this. It's a genuine topic and having...

2011-05-02T16:56:25-04:00

I'd love this. It's a genuine topic and having a way to find all posts with it will be great.

A while ago I seeded grimm's fairy tales but forgot to mention in the forum, now I think it'd make more sense to make a broader tag to cover others stories as well. +1 to fairy tale.

@Zekana: I noticed we don't seem to have a tag for...

2011-05-02T16:18:32-04:00

I noticed we don't seem to have a tag for images referencing old fairy tales or Folklore, like with post #909290 (tale of the bamboo cutter) or even for existing tags such as little_red_riding_hood.

My idea is we can create a tag, such as Fairy_tale, to help organize images that are based off of old childhood stories like little red riding hood, the three little pigs, as well as japanese stories.

another name for this tag could be Folklore, though its currently being used as an alias for folkssoul it seems.

Thoughts? would this tag be of any use if implimented?