Comments on post #1111

@AlsoSprachOdin on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2011-11-24T09:53:11-05:00

Tetrominon said:
We have a spoiler tag. It's right under the comment box. Please make use of it.

Sorry. Done.

@rtdgmdsdff on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2010-12-07T14:06:01-05:00

Well, yes, true. I never realised that until recently, though (if you can't guess who I am, just look through my previous comments...).

Not that it changes my basic point at all. No-one has a right to do this to Sakura, because she's not in any way to blame.

@RagAltima on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2010-12-07T05:21:24-05:00

rtdgmdsdff said:
No, she doesn't. Firstly, she doesn't actually know that she's harming anyone until Shirou attempts to kill her, at which point she does do that, and secondly it's entirely unreasonable to expect someone to commit suicide because they might harm others.

Well even more than that, Ilya knew everything and had an excellent way of stopping it, so you could say she is the most culpable for it. She however, had been indoctrinated by the Einzbern's, so she really didn't give a fuck about anything but her role, and then later Shirou. So it'd be a bit hypocritical her of all people to shoot Sakura.

@rtdgmdsdff on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2010-10-24T17:36:58-04:00

AlsoSprachOdin said:
I suppose that by popular moral standards she 'deserves' plenty of stuff for not killing herself as soon as she knew she posed a threat to others (a solution she eventually chose), but I honestly don't care.
Rin is just as responsible - she could have killed Sakura despite Shirou's wishes. Of course Shirou is just as guilty, and Ilya, Rider, and so on. All these... "anti-Sakura" people seem to forget that, and so I just can't respect them.

No, she doesn't. Firstly, she doesn't actually know that she's harming anyone until Shirou attempts to kill her, at which point she does do that, and secondly it's entirely unreasonable to expect someone to commit suicide because they might harm others.

@Tetrominon on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2010-10-20T12:28:37-04:00

We have a spoiler tag. It's right under the comment box. Please make use of it.

@AlsoSprachOdin on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2010-10-20T12:20:58-04:00

I suppose that by popular moral standards she 'deserves' plenty of stuff for not killing herself as soon as she knew she posed a threat to others (a solution she eventually chose), but I honestly don't care.
Rin is just as responsible - she could have killed Sakura despite Shirou's wishes. Of course Shirou is just as guilty, and Ilya, Rider, and so on. All these... "anti-Sakura" people seem to forget that, and so I just can't respect them.

@rtdgmdsdff on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2009-12-22T14:41:55-05:00

I'm not. But, unfortunately, I don't think your viewpoint is as uncommon as you think.

I'm not entirely sure of the point of doing this, though....

@Roa on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2009-12-20T23:36:40-05:00

keroko said:
... I'm probably among the few who thinks Sakura deserves this after finishing Heavens Feel.

Heh, I'm with you.

@keroko on post #1111 (illyasviel von einzbern and matou sakura (fate and 1 more) drawn by kaze_shibuki)

2009-02-15T12:14:32-05:00

... I'm probably among the few who thinks Sakura deserves this after finishing Heavens Feel.