Comments on post #2780528

@cd_young on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-13T11:48:52-04:00

Guardian54 said:
This is considered medium_breasts on Danbooru even though the *artist description says large*

Wait, don't we defer to the artist over our own opinions? He called'em large, and here we are basically telling him nope.

@Emerald_Acid on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T19:28:18-04:00

Would it still be Gameplay_Mechanics if they're just talking about it and not actually showing?

@Guardian54 on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T13:13:15-04:00

chinatsu said:

Just one of those breasts is the size of her entire face... of course it's large breasts.

No.

The breast is represented by a hemisphere, and is about chin to eyebrows and at least for the one on the right (her left) not as wide as her face. In case you weren't aware, the forehead is part of the face, so... that's a problem (let's use average of the axes for the oval, shall we?).

Breast = roughly a HEMISPHERE is the critical problem here, as a sphere with the volume of roughly the character's facial area is twice as much (completely absurd, I know)

EDIT: To clarify, this is to raise awareness to hopefully get the definition of large_breasts changed to be reasonable. It's obvious that y'all mean the area of the face fromt eh eyebrows down, so about a circle the diameter of the width of the face...

@reiyasona on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T13:05:52-04:00

Guardian54 said:

Jun'you fails this test (if barely) without even counting her forehead.

Visualization.

Guardian54 said:

This is considered medium_breasts on Danbooru even though the artist description says large:
http://danbooru.me/posts/2780865?tags=medium_breasts

Fixed.

chinatsu said:

Just one of those breasts is the size of her entire face... of course it's large breasts.

These breasts are definitely large.

@chilled_sake on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T10:53:28-04:00

Just one of those breasts is the size of her entire face... of course it's large breasts.

@gsands.g on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T10:45:50-04:00

I commented on this in topic #12825, as that seemse to be the thread where the size definitions were discussed. I suggest some of the others who feel the size definitions are off, you may want to post there as well as I suspect it will be more readily seen then posting here.

@gsands.g on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-09T10:06:59-04:00

Agree with the above comments completely. If you go by the written definition of the lower bound of large_breasts, Dolly Parton would have medium_breasts! That's ludicrous under any definitions.

@Alega on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-08T12:40:09-04:00

Guardian54 said:

I asked myself this repeatedly...

Someone who sees girls with hime cuts all the time, obviously. (And it DOES work if you put the top edge of the face at the eyebrows...)

This is considered medium_breasts on Danbooru even though the artist description says large:
http://danbooru.me/posts/2780865?tags=medium_breasts

Oh yeah, these are medium. Times two.

@Guardian54 on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-08T11:34:57-04:00

XionGaTaosenai said:

Who wrote these definitions?

I asked myself this repeatedly...

Someone who sees girls with hime cuts all the time, obviously. (And it DOES work if you put the top edge of the face at the eyebrows...)

This is considered medium_breasts on Danbooru even though the artist description says large:
http://danbooru.me/posts/2780865?tags=medium_breasts

@XionGaTaosenai on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-08T10:14:46-04:00

Guardian54 said:

Um, this shouldn't be large_breasts.

"Use this tag if the volume of a character's breast is:

Lower bound:
Greater than the volume of a sphere with the same diameter as the character's facial area"
Citing http://danbooru.me/wiki_pages/7019

Jun'you fails this test (if barely) without even counting her forehead.

Yeah, the large_breasts tag is a bit ridiculous in requirements, given that's ONE breast they're talking about, but hey...

Re-tagged as medium_breasts (to help spread awareness and get that definition of large_breasts changed).

Who wrote these definitions?

"The volume of a sphere with the same diameter as the character's facial area" is not an intuitive definition at all, and if you accept that as the definition, the difference between that and "the size of the character's head" is so negligible that there is no reason for the large breasts tag to even exist; in practice, it will just jump straight from medium to huge 90% of the time.

I feel like intuitively, large breasts should stand for any breasts that are clearly larger than the norm from a real-life perspective; any breasts that can produce cleavage without the aid of a push-up bra or other shaped garment should qualify.

@Guardian54 on post #2780528 (admiral, kaga, tenryuu, atago, sazanami, and 4 more (kantai collection and 1 more) drawn by mimofu_(fullhighkick))

2017-07-08T08:47:49-04:00

Um, this shouldn't be large_breasts.

"Use this tag if the volume of a character's breast is:

Lower bound:
Greater than the volume of a sphere with the same diameter as the character's facial area"
Citing http://danbooru.me/wiki_pages/7019

Jun'you fails this test (if barely) without even counting her forehead.

Yeah, the large_breasts tag is a bit ridiculous in requirements, given that's ONE breast they're talking about, but hey...

Re-tagged as medium_breasts (to help spread awareness and get that definition of large_breasts changed).