kill la kill SPOILER beware

@Hillside_Moose: Did a cleanup.

2017-07-12T01:05:00-04:00

Did a cleanup.

@Kikimaru: > ghostrigger said: > > bumping this once...

2017-07-04T13:58:59-04:00

ghostrigger said:

bumping this once again. was on cleaning kill_la_kill siblings and noticed plenty of kill_la_kill incest -spoilers (featuring the 2 main characters). the majority of which was tagged by a single user. is it acceptable now to tag incest as long the real relationship isn't tagged? thanks.

Sorry to bump, but it seems to be there again.
Should we remove the incest tag?

@GabrielWB: > ghostrigger said: > > Is it acceptable now...

2014-10-31T23:34:33-04:00

ghostrigger said:

Is it acceptable now to tag incest as long the real relationship isn't tagged? thanks.

Fairly sure it isn't. Incest by definition implies that two characters share some form of family connection which ofcourse is just the thing that should be spoilered.

@ghostrigger: bumping this once again. was on cleaning...

2014-10-31T23:01:23-04:00

bumping this once again. was on cleaning kill_la_kill siblings and noticed plenty of kill_la_kill incest -spoilers (featuring the 2 main characters). the majority of which was tagged by a single user. is it acceptable now to tag incest as long the real relationship isn't tagged? thanks.

@Hillside_Moose: I'd say the mk3 regalia aren't spoilers....

2014-04-05T15:08:23-04:00

I'd say the mk3 regalia aren't spoilers. There's thematic significance with the change in colors, but unless you've already watched the show it wouldn't mean anything to you.

@S1eth: Can we reach on conclusion on this? For most...

2014-04-05T09:01:32-04:00

Can we reach on conclusion on this?
For most images that are tagged spoilers, there are other images portraying the same thing without the spoilers tag.
The tag is an all-or-nothing deal. We can't have some images tagged and some not. Then all images might as well not be tagged.

Example:
symphony_regalia -spoilers (~25 images) vs symphony_regalia spoilers (~32 images)

@S1eth: Those images don't tell you whether she's a...

2014-03-30T01:38:14-04:00

Those images don't tell you whether she's a villain, ally, or whatever.
Either way, there should be clear guidelines as to what should be tagged spoiler and what shouldn't, because at the moment some images with the same content have the tag and some don't. And it takes only 1 image to spoil the show for you.

@NWF_Renim: > S1eth said: > > KlK kinda started off as an...

2014-03-29T20:43:51-04:00

S1eth said:

KlK kinda started off as an episodic villain of the week show.
And there was that one "Mako is a 2-star" episode that didn't really have any influence on the plot as a whole, so therefore her in that uniform shouldn't really spoil the plot of the show for you.

I think you can kind if take it that the fact Mako is one of the "villains of the week" to be why it is a spoiler. Not that a close friend becoming one your opponents is that unique. The episode though wasn't insignificant to the story, as it leads in to the elections fight.

Just my two cents, I don't really feel strongly one way or the other on it being labelled a spoiler or not.

@S1eth: > Log said: > The fact that Mako, a zero star...

2014-03-29T17:59:31-04:00

Log said:
The fact that Mako, a zero star student, has a starred uniform at some point is a spoiler in and of itself.

KlK kinda started off as an episodic villain of the week show.
And there was that one "Mako is a 2-star" episode that didn't really have any influence on the plot as a whole, so therefore her in that uniform shouldn't really spoil the plot of the show for you.

@Log: The fact that Mako, a zero star student, has a...

2014-03-29T11:05:13-04:00

The fact that Mako, a zero star student, has a starred uniform at some point is a spoiler in and of itself.

Satsuki's short haircut I wouldn't tag as spoilers.

The final symphony regalias are arguable, personally I would err on the side of caution.

Isshin wasn't revealed to have developed the scissor blades until episode 4-5 iirc.

Nui can be cleaned up if we're careful about her arms. Revealing a new character isn't a spoiler.

Nudist Beach gear is pretty much cosplay so that can be stripped too.

@S1eth: So now that the show has ended, I looked back...

2014-03-29T04:40:19-04:00

So now that the show has ended, I looked back at all images tagged as spoiler.
I noticed that a large number of them are only spoilers for you if you are watching the show while it airs and are exactly one week/one episode behind, at which point I'd suggest to stay away from Danbooru until you've watched it anyway.
So, there are many images that I think should not have the spoiler tag because if I haven't watched the show, looking at those images will not tell me any of the major plot points.

Some examples:

post #1649238, post #1649134 the date from the epilogue
post #1648331 Gamagoori gif from final episode
post #1646784 Sanageyama with black uniform, open eyes
symphony_regalia spoilers all of these
post #1643561 Iori in tailor_regalia
post #1594701 Ryuuko with scarf Senketsu (not to mention that this only lasted 1 episode and was completely inconsequential)
post #1576124 just Nui, most Nui images got tagged spoiler when she was just introduced
post #1588872 Ishhin with scissors (why?)
post #1565401 Sanageyama with blindfold
post #1553448 many images of Mako in her 2-star uniform

@Benit149: I only added a couple of images pertaining to...

2014-03-07T09:54:17-05:00

I only added a couple of images pertaining to Mako briefly wearing Senketsu in episode 21 in the Hilarious in Hindsight pool, but I didn't want to add every image just in case.

@Log: I cleaned it up (aside from the pools)...

2014-03-04T23:15:50-05:00

I cleaned it up (aside from the pools) yesterday, Satsuki images with the twin blades I left tagged as spoiler, if it's just the clothes and no other indicators that something's going on it's not.

@Log: Yeah, those really shouldn't have been added to...

2014-03-02T09:24:21-05:00

Yeah, those really shouldn't have been added to the pools. Spoiler maybe if they're a direct reference to the show (both outfits exactly as they appear in the show) but that's as far as I would go. Characters cosplaying as other characters in a series is super super common (copytags:1 cosplay) so the costume change becoming official isn't really anything to note.

The DTTF pool spoiled it for me as well.

@S1eth: So what is now with the latest Satsuki images...

2014-03-02T09:00:07-05:00

So what is now with the latest Satsuki images getting tagged as spoiler (+that was fast pool) and old images being added to all the Hilarious / Harsher in Hindsight pools?

codeYAHA said:
The pool and comments spoiled it for me. Thought it was just a cool picture of satsuki and senketsu.

We've had these images before, and just tagged them cosplay. I don't see a problem doing the same thing with the new ones.
Except that the screencaps from the episode are being approved for some reason.

@Benit149: As far as cosplaying, I don't think the spoiler...

2014-02-22T13:41:02-05:00

As far as cosplaying, I don't think the spoiler tag would apply since we already know that

Mikisugi Aikurou and Kinagase Tsumugu wear the Nudist Beach uniform, plus lackeys wore them during the school takeover battle. As for in-universe characters wearing them in fanart when they don't in the series, perhaps just the nudist_beach_uniform will suffice, or there could be a nudist_beach_(cosplay) tag in conjunction. It all depends on how popular this concept becomes in the future.

EDIT: And why do I need to use spoiler tags in a thread marked as SPOILER?

Why not? Some people are fanatical about staying away from spoilers, so if they somehow misclicked here and got spoiled even though the thread title says SPOILER, we'd still have some angry nerd bashing.

@S1eth: But once we get images of Ryuuko, Mako,...

2014-02-22T12:04:00-05:00

But once we get images of Ryuuko, Mako, characters from other copyrights or possibly even Ragyou with the uniform, what then? I could explain all this with a "let's put everyone in Aikurou's/Tsumugu's costume" project.

EDIT: And why do I need to use spoiler tags in a thread marked as SPOILER?

@Benit149: In the series, the Elite Four - who complied...

2014-02-22T11:38:35-05:00

In the series,

the Elite Four - who complied with Satsuki to eliminate Nudist Beach during the school takeovers from eps. 13-16 - are forced to join Nudist Beach's efforts while Satsuki goes missing due to the Covers overwhelming the populace, and they need to protect the citizens in the meantime. Considering that the Elite Four were originally Nudist Beach's enemies, seeing them join Nudist Beach (even if it's mainly out of necessity until they rejoin with Satsuki) would spoil them having to change sides in episode 19. In addition, why would the Elite Four need to wear Nudist Beach uniforms if they have their Three-Star Uniforms? Because they were destroyed from overuse while fighting against the Covers, so the Elite Four need to wear Nudist Beach's uniform.

That's why I think it warrants the spoilers tag.

@S1eth: It's either forever, or not at all. I don't...

2014-02-22T11:30:15-05:00

It's either forever, or not at all.
I don't really think the tag needs a spoilers tag.
I could just as well be some pixiv fad.

@Kikimaru: How long should spoilers last on tag ...

2014-02-22T09:48:22-05:00

How long should spoilers last on tag

nudist_beach_uniform?