create implication cat_keyhole_bra -> bra
create implication cat_keyhole_bra -> cleavage_cutout

Link to request

+1

seems self-explanatory

Shouldn't the cat_keyhole_bra tag be something like cat_lingerie? The memetic outfit includes both a top and bottom piece, so the current tag and wiki page for it is misleading.

https://twitter.com/sou_mikagami/status/691689181827837952

┐(´～`；)┌

Would probably best to simply shorten the tag to cat_keyhole to make it a catch-all for any variations and add a cat_keyhole_bra -> cat_keyhole implication. Or alias. Whichever works best.

I'd be for the implication because that way the request don't get touched.

Ars said:

https://twitter.com/sou_mikagami/status/691689181827837952

┐(´～`；)┌

Would probably best to simply shorten the tag to cat_keyhole to make it a catch-all for any variations and add a cat_keyhole_bra -> cat_keyhole implication. Or alias. Whichever works best.

The term we use for the concept though is cleavage cutout, so it's best not to use "keyhole" to refer to it when we're not using that term for the concept.

Right now the tag seems to follow a specific type of outfit, but if we want it to refer to just the cutout and its shape you'd probably have to call it like cat-shaped cleavage cutout for specifically cleavage cutouts or simply cat cutout (similar to heart_cutout) for cutouts on various parts of the outfit.

Also are these really bras? I feel like they're just adding noise to the bra tag.

NWF_Renim said:

Also are these really bras? I feel like they're just adding noise to the bra tag.

Yeah, I was wondering about that. Isn't this type of outfit called a bandeau?

I think I like feline lump's suggestion, which is to alias it to cat_lingerie (which is equivalent to the Japanese Pixiv tag). That then can be implicated to lingerie.

feline_lump said:

Shouldn't the cat_keyhole_bra tag be something like cat_lingerie? The memetic outfit includes both a top and bottom piece, so the current tag and wiki page for it is misleading.

+1 There are also matching thighhighs with ears.

Ars said:

https://twitter.com/sou_mikagami/status/691689181827837952

┐(´～`；)┌

Would probably best to simply shorten the tag to cat_keyhole to make it a catch-all for any variations and add a cat_keyhole_bra -> cat_keyhole implication. Or alias. Whichever works best.

I'd use cat_cutout similar to heart_cutout. If we go with cat_lingerie no implication since there could be topless variations.

Schrobby said:

If we go with cat_lingerie no implication since there could be topless variations.

It's still lingerie even if topless or bottomless. I'd implicate "underwear" at the very least.

I find the idea of have a cat show cleavage to be pretty cute and funny idea. Glad it was added

EB said:

It's still lingerie even if topless or bottomless. I'd implicate "underwear" at the very least.

I meant the cat_cutout since a topless variant wouldn't have that. Well, probably.

Also relevant to this topic, should this have a pool - like some other Pixiv and general fads -, or is sticking to a tag regarding the top okay?

So, if I folle the conversation:
Delete the request implication cat keyhole bra to bra but the other one can stay (if a bra has an cutout it's most likely and in this case specific a cleavage cutout.
Other thing: EB mentioned the bandeau. So should it get implicated to this tag? The same thing for (cat-)lingerie.

Alias cat_keyhole_bra to cat_lingerie.
Implicate cat_lingerie to lingerie.

Copy cat_keyhole_bra wiki to cat_lingerie wiki and add cat eared panties and thighhighs to it.

Edit: bell choker should also be added to the wiki for that outfit.

What do we do for posts like post #2257220 and post #2257148? It doesn't make sense to me to make new tags for just one or two posts, so I tagged them "you're doing it wrong" for right now.

I'd recommend a more generic "animal_cutout", and if cat_lingerie refers to the outfit as a whole, then parody outfits like that should also get tagged cat_lingerie.

Sidenote: While we do have a heart_cutout tag, the heart_cleavage_cutout tag is aliased to cleavage_cutout instead.

NWF_Renim said:

I'd recommend a more generic "animal_cutout", and if cat_lingerie refers to the outfit as a whole, then parody outfits like that should also get tagged cat_lingerie.

The bottom part could also get a tag of animal_band_panties to matching with animal_band_legwear. If they're tagged on all applicable posts, though there's a problem finding the non-cat examples (an issue with the latter tag even before this meme got started, even if minor since it's not very populated). I think that the cat bands should probably have their own tag (preferably separate in the interest of finding images like post #1692506 )

NWF_Renim said:

I'd recommend a more generic "animal_cutout", and if cat_lingerie refers to the outfit as a whole, then parody outfits like that should also get tagged cat_lingerie.

Dunno if animal_cutout is warranted. Right now we have about 300 cat cutouts and only 2 other ones that are both a parody of the outfit.

+1 to parody tagging.

EB said:

The bottom part could also get a tag of animal_band_panties to matching with animal_band_legwear. If they're tagged on all applicable posts, though there's a problem finding the non-cat examples (an issue with the latter tag even before this meme got started, even if minor since it's not very populated). I think that the cat bands should probably have their own tag (preferably separate in the interest of finding images like post #1692506 )

True, a lot of those had cat ears before, but now it's a huge majority. So something like cat_band_panties and cat_band_legwear?

Schrobby said:
So something like cat_band_panties and cat_band_legwear?

Yeah, that's what I would tag them.