create implication jumper -> dress

Link to implication

Wiki says:
A jumper, pinafore dress or pinafore is a sleeveless, collarless dress intended to be worn over a blouse, shirt or sweater.
Not to be confused with an apron, which has no back, distinctively.

Maybe it should sleeveless, too. Didn't saw that part...

Looking through the tag there are cases of posts that are not dresses (post #2251868, post #1936657), suspender_skirts (post #1681684), and posts that probably should be cleared up if they're dresses or skirts (post #2158527).

For the first two, if the jumper is a dress they need to be cleaned from the tag. For the last one, we need to define at what point it is a dress and what point it is a skirt.

Which leads to a language-specific question:
How is this word used? The first examples are vests but is that word also used there?
The second example isn't a dress, or? And the definition says that the dress is worn over the shirt (yes, the suspenders are worn over the dress, but that would only hardly fall unter this and complicates things).
The third one is a high-waist_skirt, since it doesn't cover the bust.

I thought you were talking about sweaters. Better question might be, does it need a better tag in the first place?

SciFi said:

I thought you were talking about sweaters. Better question might be, does it need a better tag in the first place?

Yeah, "jumper" in British English is a type of sweater, so it's not a best name for the tag.

To quote "Jumper" disambiguation page in Wikipedia:

Jumper (U.S. English; known elsewhere as a pinafore dress)

To make things worse, according to Wikipedia page, pinafore (which is currently aliased to jumper) is a type of apron, and the correct term to use would be pinafore_dress.

I'd like to propose that pinafore be unaliased from jumper and that jumper be aliased over to pinafore_dress. Pinafore_dress then can implicate dress.

Can have a note under the pinafore_dress tag wiki directing users to sweater if necessary due to the jumper alias.

NWF_Renim said:

I'd like to propose that pinafore be unaliased from jumper and that jumper be aliased over to pinafore_dress. Pinafore_dress then can implicate dress.

Can have a note under the pinafore_dress tag wiki directing users to sweater if necessary due to the jumper alias.

+1

NWF_Renim said:

I'd like to propose that pinafore be unaliased from jumper and that jumper be aliased over to pinafore_dress. Pinafore_dress then can implicate dress.

Can have a note under the pinafore_dress tag wiki directing users to sweater if necessary due to the jumper alias.

Agree.

+1

remove alias pinafore -> jumper
create alias jumper -> pinafore_dress
create implication pinafore_dress -> dress

Link to request

The bulk update request #784 has been approved.

The tag implication jumper -> dress has been rejected.