[REJECTED] Tag alias: red_lipstick -> red_lips

@user_429955: Is there a resolution to this topic? The way...

2018-12-09T11:55:04-05:00

Is there a resolution to this topic? The way that the wiki is written now makes it seem like both red lips and red lipstick tube should implicate red lipstick, while not mentioning any other situation where lips would appear red.

The wiki for red lipstick says: A tube of lipstick or makeup applied to the lips that is colored red.
The wiki for red lips says: When a character has applied red-colored lipstick to their lips.

The rest of the lips colors are very similar:

Wiki for pink lipstick: A tube of lipstick or makeup applied to the lips that is colored pink.
Wiki for pink lips: Lips that have pink lipstick applied to them.

Rest of colors tags:

@DanbooruBot: The tag alias red_lipstick -> red_lips has...

2018-04-27T14:43:23-04:00

The tag alias red_lipstick -> red_lips has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

@DanbooruBot: This tag alias has been rejected because it was...

2018-04-27T14:43:23-04:00

This tag alias has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.

@BrokenEagle98: > Provence said: > > I guess it's better to...

2017-03-12T10:12:51-04:00

Provence said:

I guess it's better to change the definition of the wiki and let the tag only be used for the first case before the "or":
A tube of (red) lipstick
That would mean -1 to this alias.

+1 to this.

@user_460797: I guess it's better to change the definition of...

2017-03-12T06:55:17-04:00

I guess it's better to change the definition of the wiki and let the tag only be used for the first case before the "or":
A tube of (red) lipstick
That would mean -1 to this alias.

@iridescent_slime: Just one thing: what will this alias do for the...

2017-03-12T06:52:57-04:00

Just one thing: what will this alias do for the red lipstick -> lipstick implication? Should red lips imply lipstick?

@chilled_sake: > Provence said: > > I guess that this tag is...

2017-03-12T01:37:43-05:00

Provence said:

I guess that this tag is also color specific. Lipstick tube is not color specific.
But I agree (if that's somehow your intention): Having one tag for two possible things is kinda iffy.

It's not color specific but it could be. That's what I suggest in the original post.

For another ciriticism in this thread, would applied lipstick suffice? Or maybe this should just be an implication?

Gollgagh said:

We already have a lipstick tube tag for when it's separate; is there any reason to keep both under the same tag?

That's why I feel this is shoehorning concepts together. They should be seperate.

tapnek said:

Is this a setup for a bunch of *_lips tags in place of *_lipstick?

Yes :)

@user_460797: I guess that this tag is also color specific....

2017-03-10T14:00:18-05:00

I guess that this tag is also color specific. Lipstick tube is not color specific.
But I agree (if that's somehow your intention): Having one tag for two possible things is kinda iffy.

@Gollgagh: We already have a lipstick tube tag for when...

2017-03-10T13:59:06-05:00

We already have a lipstick tube tag for when it's separate; is there any reason to keep both under the same tag?

@user_460797: The wiki says in any case this: A tube of...

2017-03-10T13:50:17-05:00

The wiki says in any case this:
A tube of lipstick or makeup applied to the lips that is colored red.

@Mikaeri: Isn't there the possibility that someone might...

2017-03-10T13:48:37-05:00

Isn't there the possibility that someone might just use this with actual 'red' lipstick? That isn't applied to the lips (yet, at least)?

Neither for or against at the moment, but I'm just throwing it out there.

@Kikimaru: +1 With the fact that many pieces also can...

2017-03-10T13:28:38-05:00

With the fact that many pieces also can have non-human skin colours, I'd also back a *_lipstick -> *_lips alias.

@tapnek: Is this a setup for a bunch of *_lips tags in...

2017-03-09T06:47:46-05:00

Is this a setup for a bunch of *_lips tags in place of *_lipstick?

@user_441999: Hmm... lips can be red without lipstick having...

2017-03-09T04:39:13-05:00

Hmm... lips can be red without lipstick having been applied. I'm not sure there's any way of telling that with posts on this site, though. Except in cases of monochrome posts which probably don't want this tag anyway.

Hypothetical example, but what if the red lips were on a figure or a painting (object) or similar? Probably not much of an issue, though.

I guess on balance I'd agree to this, but it's a rather cautious agreement.

@chilled_sake: create alias red_lipstick -> red_lips Link to...

2017-03-09T03:03:41-05:00

create alias red_lipstick -> red_lips

Link to alias

The wiki pages seem to describe the same thing. Except the red lipstick page seems to allow for wiggle room for red lipstick that isn't on a character's lips but rather just a tube of lipstick. Such cases would be better suited as branch off of x_lipstick_tube rather than shoehorning the two concepts in one tag that interferes with a very similar one.

EDIT: This tag alias has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.

EDIT: The tag alias red_lipstick -> red_lips has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.