Tag Discussion: Mother

@jxh2154: Aliases and implications made as suggested. I...

2008-12-20T00:50:04-05:00

Aliases and implications made as suggested. I also mass edited the mother tag to mother_(game) so the mother tag is now free. mother was already made ambiuous. I'll copy the wiki over too.

Now someone just needs to go through and correctly tag as _1, _2, _3.

@NeverGonnaGive: coughs Also, it's weird to look at "mother"...

2008-12-19T23:05:18-05:00

*coughs*
Also, it's weird to look at "mother" and see "moth-er".

@jxh2154: > EmperorBrandon said: The only problem with...

2008-11-14T10:38:05-05:00

EmperorBrandon said: The only problem with using mother_(game) for the whole series is that it would seem like it's only referring to first game at first glance

Possibly, but if it's always an implication from _1 _2 _3, and thus appears alongside one or more of them, then I think that should clear up most of the confusion. I don't think we'd run into too many people using it wrongly.

@EB: The only problem with using mother_(game) for...

2008-11-14T10:26:54-05:00

The only problem with using mother_(game) for the whole series is that it would seem like it's only referring to first game at first glance (which is just called "Mother" - I'm not against adding a "1" for tag purposes, though, as was done with Final Fantasy and others).

@jxh2154: The proposed aliases to mother_1 2 and 3 sound...

2008-11-14T10:04:49-05:00

The proposed aliases to mother_1 2 and 3 sound reasonable. Separate tags are justified by the differing casts.

As for the implications, a qualifier would be good, with _(game) probably being the better choice. We only use _(series) in two tags, _(game) in 15 or so. Neither are bad ideas, but _(game) is just more common.

@evazion: I was planning on suggesting these...

2008-11-13T19:13:22-05:00

I was planning on suggesting these aliases/implications myself. Each game in the series has a separate cast so they shouldn't all be lumped together under one tag.

I agree with T5J8F8's suggestions, except I think each game should implicate to mother_(series). Doing that will free up the mother tag so that it's no longer ambiguous.

@NeverGonnaGive: > memegui said: > Why not alias them all to...

2008-11-13T18:07:24-05:00

memegui said:
Why not alias them all to mother, or preferably mother_(game).

Well, unlike LoZ where you perenially have a Link, a Zelda, and a Ganon[dorf] (and, in some cases, direct sequelage, such a MM and PH), the MOTHER games seem more individualized, at least as far as playable cast goes. Don't they de-serve re-cog-NI-tion?! </dramatics>

@memegui: Why not alias them all to mother, or preferably...

2008-11-13T16:08:06-05:00

Why not alias them all to mother, or preferably mother_(game).

@NeverGonnaGive: As it stands... earthbound aliases to mother_2...

2008-11-13T15:57:16-05:00

As it stands...
earthbound aliases to mother_2
earthbound_zero aliases to mother
mother_3 aliases to mother

May this be changed to...
ALIASES
earthbound to mother_2
earthbound_zero to mother_1
IMPLICATIONS
mother_1 to mother
mother_2 to mother
mother_3 to mother

Since (IIRC) the standing policy to to implicate individual games to a series tag when those games share the same world and/or characters. I feel that the Legend of Zelda approach is a bit much for a series with so few entries.