Danbooru

[REJECTED] Ice cream

Posted under Tags

Neapolitan is kind of distinctive, including visually, in ways that single flavours of ice cream generally aren't.

That said if the consensus is to get rid of it then I won't object.

I feel like I'm on the wrong side of the "detailed tags are good" vs "detailed tags are bad" debate, but I would also argue that chocolate_mint_ice_cream is visually distinct in a way that say chocolate, vanilla, strawberry or other monochromatic flavors are not, since it's got the "blue/green with brown/green inclusions" pattern to it. I don't know if it's tremendously useful or not, but I've also seen it used as a "theme" for characters moreso than other flavors (e.g. Gyari's ChocoMinto Ice music video)

@Shinjidude Actually, I agree with you. It's a much more distinctive look than tags like blue_ice_cream (may that tag never be seen again), and there were indeed a number of mint chip themed outfits and/or personifications that had this tag at the time of the ice cream tag purge: post #1194217 and post #2109496 and post #2399120, for example.

I guess I should have added a corollary to my last reply — if we're not going to nuke the tag again, we should restore it to the posts that previously had it.

  • 1
  • 2