[REJECTED] Tag implication: bridal_gauntlets -> gloves

@DanbooruBot: The tag implication bridal_gauntlets -> gloves...

2018-06-12T02:30:44-04:00

The tag implication bridal_gauntlets -> gloves (forum #147695) has been rejected by @Hillside_Moose.

@nonamethanks: > yelite said: > > Can we just switch those...

2018-06-08T11:52:06-04:00

yelite said:

Can we just switch those "color gloves" tags to "color handwear" (similar to eyewear and legwear tags)? I wanna use them on mittens and oven mitts.

I couldn't see bridal gauntlets as gloves because most of the time they don't really cover the whole hand. Even if they are gloves, "bridal gauntlets" look different enough to seperate them with gloves (mittens as well). The implication might just add noise into the gloves tag.

That could work. Might be a pain to garden those posts out though, and to enforce such usage.

@yelite: Can we just switch those "color gloves" tags to...

2018-06-08T11:44:57-04:00

Can we just switch those "color gloves" tags to "color handwear" (similar to eyewear and legwear tags)? I wanna use them on mittens and oven mitts.

I couldn't see bridal gauntlets as gloves because most of the time they don't really cover the whole hand. Even if they are gloves, "bridal gauntlets" look different enough to seperate them with gloves (mittens as well). The implication might just add noise into the gloves tag.

@nonamethanks: > Unbreakable said: > > I didn't know we were...

2018-06-08T11:03:51-04:00

Unbreakable said:

I didn't know we were supposed to tag them with elbow gloves or colour_gloves tags at all, if elbow-length is the norm shouldn't we tag the exception rather?

Either way I say they are different from gloves.

I've started tagging the colored versions after I saw people tagging them - same with the elbow thing. Also pretty much every definition of gauntlet I could find describes them as gloves (like the wikipedia page ).

If they're not gloves, then do we need separate color tags for them? Because otherwise we'll still have over 3k mistagged posts.

@Unbreakable: I didn't know we were supposed to tag them with...

2018-06-08T10:59:46-04:00

I didn't know we were supposed to tag them with elbow gloves or colour_gloves tags at all, if elbow-length is the norm shouldn't we tag the exception rather?

Either way I say they are different from gloves.

@nonamethanks: create implication bridal_gauntlets -> gloves ...

2018-06-08T10:55:32-04:00

create implication bridal_gauntlets -> gloves

Link to implication

Not sure why this was not requested before. I could not find any topic about it either.

Bridal gauntles are gloves. They are already receiving the gloves tag whenever someone decides to tag them as elbow_gloves (to distinguish them from smaller bridal gauntlets), and whenever someone tags their color (Post count for bridal_gauntlets gloves: 3802).

EDIT: The tag implication bridal_gauntlets -> gloves (forum #147695) has been rejected by @Hillside_Moose.