Shouldn't there be a Cu_Chulainn_(all) tag?

@willsolvit: > Rollingplasma4 said: > > Yet saber name is...

2018-08-15T03:09:52-04:00

Rollingplasma4 said:

Yet saber name is not considered a spoiler. Also anyone who looks up lancer art will most likely be spoiled his true name since cu chulainn (fate/grand order) and cu chulainn alter (fate/grand order) are implications under lancer someone can easily click a picture containing them and spoil lancer identity when searching for lancer art. Another thing the wiki page for the lancer tag does not even spoiler his true name on the wiki page unlike archer wiki page.

I wouldn't use that as a reliable precedent considering how many people opposed it while it was happening.

@Benit149: > feline_lump said: > > Maybe a minor point,...

2018-08-13T17:06:01-04:00

feline_lump said:

Maybe a minor point, but Cu Chulainn's name is identical to the mythological figure he's based on, unlike Artoria Pendragon, so other Cu Chulainns exist outside the Fate copyright.

The umbrella tag would just be cu_chulainn_(fate)_(all) to get around that problem, same as with any other *_(fate)_(all) tags.

I seriously had no idea that Lancer's true identity was considered a spoiler on Danbooru though. FSN Archer and F/Zero Berserker I can understand, but not FSN Lancer. Oh well. I didn't participate in the discussion, so I'm not going to open that can of worms.

@feline_lump: Maybe a minor point, but Cu Chulainn's name is...

2018-08-13T16:19:16-04:00

Maybe a minor point, but Cu Chulainn's name is identical to the mythological figure he's based on, unlike Artoria Pendragon, so other Cu Chulainns exist outside the Fate copyright.

@nonamethanks: Well, you can see the 14 pages of topic #13728...

2018-08-13T15:26:22-04:00

Well, you can see the 14 pages of topic #13728 for reference on how the last discussion on the matter went. F/GO tags are already pretty messy, I doubt we're gonna find a middle ground any time soon.

@Rollingplasma4: > nonamethanks said: > > Same reason as archer...

2018-08-13T14:12:26-04:00

nonamethanks said:

Same reason as archer or rider, because of spoilers for the original game.

Yet saber name is not considered a spoiler. Also anyone who looks up lancer art will most likely be spoiled his true name since cu chulainn (fate/grand order) and cu chulainn alter (fate/grand order) are implications under lancer someone can easily click a picture containing them and spoil lancer identity when searching for lancer art. Another thing the wiki page for the lancer tag does not even spoiler his true name on the wiki page unlike archer wiki page.

@nonamethanks: Same reason as archer or rider, because of...

2018-08-13T03:14:41-04:00

Same reason as archer or rider, because of spoilers for the original game.

@Rollingplasma4: I noticed that Cu Chulainn tags do not follow...

2018-08-12T20:41:13-04:00

I noticed that Cu Chulainn tags do not follow the same format as the other servants when it comes to tagging. To clarify his lancer version does not have it own separate tag unlike Artoria who has Artoria Pendragon (all) and saber.