[REJECTED] Unification of torn legwear tags

@RiderFan: > Unbreakable said: > > It's not like this is...

2018-10-25T05:29:30-04:00

Unbreakable said:

It's not like this is the first time this has happened, again, I don't see the harm of grouping them all together for this tag.

By the context of the post it meant doing away with the tags of thighhighs, pantyhose, etc. and aliasing them all to one tag called legwear.
But, I will offer a small argument against the use of torn_legwear: it encourages lazy tagging.

@Unbreakable: > RiderFan said: > > Could this be a sign that...

2018-10-24T19:37:24-04:00

RiderFan said:

Could this be a sign that thighhighs, leggings, pantyhose, could all be unified under the singular tag of legwear? Why dumb down accurate search queries?

It's not like this is the first time this has happened, again, I don't see the harm of grouping them all together for this tag.

@RiderFan: Could this be a sign that thighhighs, leggings,...

2018-10-24T19:03:58-04:00

Could this be a sign that thighhighs, leggings, pantyhose, could all be unified under the singular tag of legwear? Why dumb down accurate search queries?

@Shinjidude: I thought we were going to keep torn_pantyhose...

2018-10-23T22:32:28-04:00

I thought we were going to keep torn_pantyhose separate as the dominant and more distinct case here. I guess torn_legwear -pantyhose works to some degree (maybe not as well with multiple characters), but they sort of feel different to me, given the pantyhose version is so common and the others fairly rare.

@fossilnix: It got rejected by the 60-day timer, then...

2018-10-23T01:59:21-04:00

It got rejected by the 60-day timer, then re-submitted and approved.

@keonas: I am confused, was this approved or not? ...

2018-10-23T01:51:22-04:00

I am confused, was this approved or not?

Should we start re-writing the torn legwear wiki?

@DanbooruBot: The tag alias torn_pantyhose -> torn_legwear ...

2018-10-23T01:12:48-04:00

The tag alias torn_pantyhose -> torn_legwear has conflicting wiki pages. torn_legwear should be updated to include information from torn_pantyhose if necessary.

@DanbooruBot: The tag alias torn_thighhighs -> torn_legwear ...

2018-10-23T00:57:13-04:00

The tag alias torn_thighhighs -> torn_legwear has conflicting wiki pages. torn_legwear should be updated to include information from torn_thighhighs if necessary.

@DanbooruBot: The bulk update request #1832 (forum #151626)...

2018-10-23T00:08:18-04:00

The bulk update request #1832 (forum #151626) has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.

@DanbooruBot: The tag alias torn_pantyhose -> torn_legwear ...

2018-10-23T00:08:18-04:00

The tag alias torn_pantyhose -> torn_legwear has conflicting wiki pages. torn_legwear should be updated to include information from torn_pantyhose if necessary.

@DanbooruBot: The tag alias torn_thighhighs -> torn_legwear ...

2018-10-23T00:08:18-04:00

The tag alias torn_thighhighs -> torn_legwear has conflicting wiki pages. torn_legwear should be updated to include information from torn_thighhighs if necessary.

@Hillside_Moose: mass update torn_socks -> torn_legwear mass...

2018-10-23T00:07:59-04:00

mass update torn_socks -> torn_legwear
mass update torn_kneehighs -> torn_legwear
mass update torn_leggings -> torn_legwear
create alias torn_thighhighs -> torn_legwear
create alias torn_pantyhose -> torn_legwear
create implication torn_legwear -> torn_clothes

Link to request

EDIT: The bulk update request #1832 (forum #151626) has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.

@DanbooruBot: The bulk update request #1818 (forum #151116)...

2018-10-23T00:06:54-04:00

The bulk update request #1818 (forum #151116) has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.

@DanbooruBot: The bulk update request #1778 (forum #149796)...

2018-10-22T20:02:15-04:00

The bulk update request #1778 (forum #149796) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

@DanbooruBot: This bulk update request has been rejected...

2018-10-22T20:02:14-04:00

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.

@DanbooruBot: This bulk update request is pending automatic...

2018-10-17T20:02:18-04:00

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

@EB: > Shinjidude said: > > I think all of this is...

2018-10-06T00:12:30-04:00

Shinjidude said:

I think all of this is fine, except that I'd either exclude or make an implication instead of an alias for torn_pantyhose. It's common enough and distinct enough, that it would swamp the general tag I think and make most of the content in the other tags a lot harder to find.

Yeah, I think that was the point of keeping pantyhose and other types of legwear separate in the first place, even as the other tags were being consolidated. Torn pantyhose is far more common.

@Shinjidude: I think all of this is fine, except that I'd...

2018-10-05T23:52:42-04:00

I think all of this is fine, except that I'd either exclude or make an implication instead of an alias for torn_pantyhose. It's common enough and distinct enough, that it would swamp the general tag I think and make most of the content in the other tags a lot harder to find.

@EB: remove implication torn_thighhighs ->...

2018-10-05T23:51:07-04:00

remove implication torn_thighhighs -> thighhighs
remove implication torn_pantyhose -> pantyhose

Link to request

The existing implications need to be removed first before the aliases are done.

EDIT: The bulk update request #1818 (forum #151116) has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.

@Unbreakable: Bump on this, it would be nice if a decision...

2018-10-05T20:19:07-04:00

Bump on this, it would be nice if a decision could be made.