Aliasing magic_penis -> disembodied_penis.
Aliasing magic_tongue -> disembodied_tongue.

Reason: To fit with the distinction between magic_hand and disembodied_limb.

-1. If magic_hand is being used for the device, then a better alternative is changing the tag we use for it. Magic hand is likely just a brand for those devices, and the wiki is wrong. They aren't just toys, they are actual tools. From a quick googling of them they can be referred to as a "reacher_tool" or "reacher_grabber." They are sold for a variety of purposes, all of which rely on extending the reach of the user. Some are toys, but by large the more important purpose is assisting the elderly or infirm. They are also used for cleaning, safely picking up garbage without having to bend over or touching what might have germs or sharp parts.

Why exactly do we prefer "magic" over "disembodied"? The latter makes more consistent sense for what is being tagged. We need to alias these one way or the other.

"Magic" implies the oddity of the thing, whereas "disembodied" sounds a lot more like guro. I don't really like either of them, but prefer the former.

OOZ662 said:
whereas "disembodied" sounds a lot more like guro.

That would be more like "dismembered" (which we have the "severed" tags for) than "disembodied".

EB said:

That would be more like "dismembered" (which we have the "severed" tags for) than "disembodied".

Yeah, when I think "disembodied" I think of "x out of nowhere."

+1 for disembodied, seems more accurate and intuitive than magic.

No issue if consensus wants to aliases these over to keep them consistent in naming, though I don't see a reason to make the magic_tongue alias. It has no wiki and only has 5 images, it could just be edited over to the new tag.

Done

So I guess there's agreement on the current wiki definition for magic_hand? That one will need some cleanup if we're sticking to it (maybe an alias to one of the terms NWF Renim proposed above too, to prevent future confusion).