Danbooru

Tag Alias: ass -> buttocks (deleted)

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

0xCCBA696 said:
+1, not that anyone is going to listen to me.

BTW, we also still have the pussy and (lol) pussy juice tags, fwiw.

I thought the reasoning for the pussy tag was that using vagina wasn't completely correct, and vulva doesn't catch all images depicting the female genitalia.

...That said, I support this alias.

+1 for buttocks.

Soljashy said:
+1 for replacing vulgar terms.

We can' really complain of vulgarity when Danbooru has questionable pics :D maybe safebooru can complain.

Scalar said:
We can' really complain of vulgarity when Danbooru has questionable pics :D

Questionable is not always vulgar. And besides, I can choose what pics to look at.

I must reckon I tend to support "vulgar" wordings in these disputes, mainly because the only other option is so often Latin or Greek based physiological terminology. I just do not fancy penis, for example.

In the case of ass vs. buttocks, I would almost vote for the latter. It is not posterior, after all, but rather belongs to the same neutral vocabulary as breasts. (What is the equivalent of flat_ass if buttocks is used?)

However, is such a change really worth the trouble when Danbooru still has tags like cum_on_clothes? The discussion in forum #26872 is telling me that we are not consistently headed towards encyclopedic terminology.

I say +1 leave it as it is. "Ass" really isn't that vulgar, and "buttocks" sounds extremely stodgy. "Butt" is fine, but I don't know it's even worth messing with.

jxh2154 said:
I definitely prefer to leave it (and the ~20 related tags) as is.

Yeah, since [ass] is such a sexual focus, its derivative tags benefit from the "vulgarity" and brevity.

T5J8F8 said:
Yeah, since [ass] is such a sexual focus, its derivative tags benefit from the "vulgarity" and brevity.

I disagree here, but I will admit that "ass" isn't as vulgar as some other terms we use here (that need to be abolished imo).

That said, I still support the alias. It's not like we're arguing to call it gluteus_maximus_muscle or something like that.

I suppose we'd also have to change the name of the "Dat Ass" pool to "Dem Buttocks", and in this case, I'd back "Dat Ass" up.

+1 ass