It's just borderline bad (Satou's right leg being the only thing to really strike me). But really this thread is starting to sound like we want half of the contributors to reapply, so to speak. The ever increasing approval threshold is turning this discrepancy into a joke lately, may it look like hypocrisis or apathy.
So, speaking of this:
post #744594
post #742241
post #719380
All of them have been appealed by their uploader already (who apparently indiscriminately appeals all of his deletions, which could be the cause, but at least I think he has a point with these ones).
No kidding they're average, and they'd look too dull to make me upload them, yet they still look fine for approval to me.
post #744594 > I'm a stranger to Umineko but that's nice, and I can see the china dress as a plus, originality speaking.
post #742241 > Again, dull to non Umineko enthusiasts seems like the only real flaw, and we have dull posts approved every day.
post #719380 > Possible B★RS overflow? But this one looks nice too, even with the weird proportions.
I can understand these to draw little attention in the mod queue, but I'd also suspect some lack of interest in the deletion appeal thread (with stuff like forum #47846 taking I don't know how many days to get fixed, and so on).