Should handwrap be aliased to handwraps or vice versa?

The second question would a wrap tag be worth adding? If so would would you imply handwrap, legwrap, and any other types of "wraps" -> wrap.

Sorry about all the questions, just trying to tag as many distinct features on the images as I can.

Siegmund_200% said:
Should handwrap be aliased to handwraps or vice versa?

They don't necessarily come in pairs, and the wrappings are typically done with one continuous length of cloth, so handwrap.

The second question would a wrap tag be worth adding? If so would would you imply handwrap, legwrap, and any other types of "wraps" -> wrap.

It probably depends on how you would define a wrap tag. Be as specific as possible.

If those other ones are implicated to it, then sarashi should also imply wrap.

Sorry about all the questions, just trying to tag as many distinct features on the images as I can.

Not a problem. However, this thread is pretty close in similarity to the other one, so it might have been better just to keep it to one thread.

sgcdonmai said:
They don't necessarily come in pairs, and the wrappings are typically done with one continuous length of cloth, so handwrap.

It probably depends on how you would define a wrap tag. Be as specific as possible.

If those other ones are implicated to it, then sarashi should also imply wrap.

Not a problem. However, this thread is pretty close in similarity to the other one, so it might have been better just to keep it to one thread.

Ya I will keep it as one from now on (or less of them). I just wanted to keep the tag alias/implication separate form the tag name question. I guess it was not really necessary.

I will use this one as a sort of mega thread for the time being. I also changed title to be more generic. Which brings up:

hugging_knees -> leg_hug

I find myself wanting to tag hugging_knees but the tag does not exist and there is no reason to add it as a tag already exists.

The tag knee_hug is aliased to leg_hug, so is it possible to add hugging_knees to the alias list for leg_hug?

Also

post #16245

Specifically Sakuya holding her left arm. There are two single entry tags

arm_hold_around_front and arm_hold_around_back

This would be the case for the former but it seems redundent to have two tags like this since you can use arms_behind_back + arm_hold or arm_hug or something to that effect.

arm_hold and both arm_hug could be used in other places, the former being in bondage the latter when a girl holds your arm and puts her head against it, unless that has a tag already.

Last one for the moment

post #16296

interlocked_fingers and hands_clasped seem to be essentially identical.

I know scg suggested condensing threads but it's really hard for me to follow half a dozen completely different requests in the same thread. I'd prefer separate threads for ideas not conceptually linked. "What to name it" and "Should we alias it" are similar enough for one thread, "Can we have a wrap tag" and "should interlocked_fingers and hands_clasped" be aliased are not related at all.

Siegmund_200% said: Should handwrap be aliased to handwraps or vice versa?

Do we have a definition for this? It seems to overlap with bandages.

The second question would a wrap tag be worth adding?

Would have to be defined very well for such an ambiguous word, an in the process of trying to define it we may come up with a better word.

How would sarashi relate to this setup?

Siegmund_200% said: hugging_knees -> leg_hug

Done.

post #16245
Specifically Sakuya holding her left arm.

Pose/body position tags like this tend to be tricky to define so I'd prefer a separate thread. arm_hold is currently aliased to arm_grab which seems to include both self-grabs and being grabbed by others. We might need to discuss this more specifically.

post #16296
interlocked_fingers and hands_clasped seem to be essentially identical.

Yeah, their wiki definitions are almost identical. Aliased to hands_clasped.

jxh2154 said:
How would sarashi relate to this setup?

Well, if we're using arm wraps and leg wraps as an example, then a sarashi isn't really any different except in placement - a single contiguous piece of cloth wrapped many times around a body part, ostensibly to stabilize or protect that body part.

jxh2154 said:
I know scg suggested condensing threads but it's really hard for me to follow half a dozen completely different requests in the same thread. I'd prefer separate threads for ideas not conceptually linked.

Got that feeling when asking about a tagging "superthread". Will keep them separate. I think I just misunderstood sgcdonmai about condensing. It came about from my having two similar concepts in two different threads (about wraps).

Do we have a definition for this? It seems to overlap with bandages.

Best description would be

Bandage: Used to heal an injury and protect from further injure. Eg. Bandaging a sprained hand.

Hand wrap: Used to help protect against injury. Eg. A boxer putting on his hand wraps before a fight.

Generally only "fighters" use wraps while anyone can use a bandage.

Would have to be defined very well for such an ambiguous word, an in the process of trying to define it we may come up with a better word.

The above sound ok? Just generalize it more.

Pose/body position tags like this tend to be tricky to define so I'd prefer a separate thread. arm_hold is currently aliased to arm_grab which seems to include both self-grabs and being grabbed by others. We might need to discuss this more specifically.

Will do.

Siegmund_200% said:
Generally only "fighters" use wraps while anyone can use a bandage.

I would leave this part out. It seems like extraneous information, and might lead to confusion over the tag definition.

sgcdonmai said:
I would leave this part out. It seems like extraneous information, and might lead to confusion over the tag definition.

Oops, it was intended as just extra info and not meant to be part of the definition. It was sleepy and I forgot to mention that.