Lunatic6 said: Since Marisa is Gandalf then Alice is Saruman and her dolls are the Uruk-hai.
Hahaha correct! That was actually what I had in my mind when picking Marisa as Gandalf.
The hobbits are all from Team Nineball (9) which consist of Cirno, Dai, Wriggle and Misty with Letty as the famous Bilbo Baggins. Reimu as Aragorn is already a given fact while I choose Aya as Legolas because Tengu ears are pointy and Nitori is Gimli because Kappa love working with machines just like the Dwarves.
I forgot to mention but I think Sakuya should be Boromir in order for Remilia to play as Steward of Gondor and Mei Ling as Faramir. Would love to see the scene in which Marisa and Misty visits the Scarlet Devil sitting on her throne sulking while clutching the broken pocket watch of Sakuya.
<Marisa and Misty enters the SDM throne room>
Msrisa: Hail Remilia daughter of Vlad Tepes of Wallachia, Lady and steward of Scarlet Devil Mansion! I come with tidings in this dark hour and with counsel.
Remilia: <Sulking> Then perhaps you've come to me to explain this? <Shows Sakuya's broken pocket watch> Perhaps you've come to tell me why my servant is dead?
Mystia: Sakuya died to save us, my kinsmen and me. She fell defending us from many foes!
Marisa: Mystia!
Mystia: <Kneels before Remilia> I offer you my service, a servant of the SCarlet Devil... In payment of this debt...
Remilia: <Looks at Mystia> Then consider this as my first command, how did you escaped and my maid did not? Such a mighty warrior was she and you clearly not?
Mystia: A mighty a warrior may be slain by one knife yet Sakuya was pierced by many.
Then a few scenes later we get this one...
Remilia: Can you sing master sparrow?
Mystia: Well yes, at least well enough for my people. But we don't have songs for great halls for evil times...
Remilia: And why would your songs be unfit for my halls? Come, sing me a song.
Mystia: Home is behind... The world up ahead...
Cue a scene of Mei Ling charging into a horde of Dolls and Onis.
Hmm, based on what raven013 has going there I'd cast Rumia as Gollum rather than Orin. Why? Well, Gollum's a former hobbit that likes to lurk in the dark, Rumia is a youkai of darkness counted among Team ⑨ - you do the math.